RWBY: Official Manga Anthology Review

This review dives into RWBY: Official Manga Anthology Vol. 1 Red Like Roses and Vol. 2 Mirror, Mirror, exploring how these character focused stories add or fail to add depth to the beloved RWBY anime. From inconsistent art to scattered storytelling, I share my personal highs and lows after reading these anthologies on ComicK.

A Personal Take on RWBY’s Anthology

I first stumbled across RWBY: Official Manga Anthology while browsing ComicK, curious to see if the side stories would give me something fresh beyond the anime. On the surface, the idea felt exciting: little slices of Ruby and Weiss’s lives, drawn by different artists, each promising a new perspective. But as I made my way through both volumes, I couldn’t shake the mixed feelings that lingered. Some chapters charmed me with their lighthearted humor, while others left me wondering why they existed at all.

What struck me early on was how much these books assumed prior knowledge. If you’re new to RWBY, this anthology won’t hold your hand. In fact, it throws you straight into the character dynamics without pausing to explain who’s who. As someone already familiar with the anime, I could keep up but even then, I found myself puzzled at the narrative jumps.

Still, there’s something fun about revisiting characters you already love. Ruby’s awkward attempts at romance, Weiss’s icy pride softening in moments of friendship those beats worked for me on a nostalgic level. They reminded me why I got hooked on RWBY in the first place.

Volume 1: Red Like Roses – Ruby’s Slice of Life

The first volume focuses on Ruby Rose, and in typical Ruby fashion, it mixes innocence with determination. One of the standout moments had Ruby trying to step out of her shy comfort zone to look for a boyfriend. It’s awkward, funny, and honestly endearing especially if you already know her as the scythe-wielding optimist.

But here’s the thing: not every story lands. Some scenes feel stretched thin, with too little happening to justify the page count. I caught myself skimming through certain chapters, hoping for more substance. And because each short is handled by a different artist, Ruby’s personality sometimes felt inconsistent.

That said, there are gems in this volume. I laughed out loud at moments where her teammates teased her, giving the book a warm, relatable vibe. When RWBY shines, it’s usually because of their group chemistry and this volume had flashes of that magic.

Volume 2: Mirror, Mirror The Weiss Perspective

The second volume shifts focus to Weiss Schnee, who has always been a fascinating character: privileged, polished, yet yearning for independence. This book digs into her background, showing glimpses of her pampered upbringing and her growth at Beacon Academy. For fans invested in Weiss’s character arc, this is a treat.

However, the execution left me divided. The stories often jump back and forth in time, sometimes abruptly. One chapter would show Weiss as a young girl, the next would drop me into her current school life, and then suddenly we’re back again to childhood. While the intent was to layer her character, the whiplash pacing sometimes dulled the emotional impact.

What did stand out were the lighter, almost absurd moments. There’s one scene where Weiss’s cookies turn out so hard that Team RWBY decides to use them as weapons. Silly? Absolutely. But it’s the kind of playful humor that makes RWBY endearing, and it gave me a rare chuckle.

The Art: A Mixed Bag of Styles

One of the anthology’s most obvious quirks is that each story is drawn by a different artist. At first, this sounded like a strength: variety, fresh takes, and stylistic experimentation. In practice, though, it was hit or miss. Some chapters looked polished and expressive, while others felt rushed, with empty backgrounds and stiff characters.

This inconsistency made it hard to stay immersed. When Weiss’s design changes drastically from one chapter to the next, it jars the reading flow. On ComicK, the digital quality was sharp, but the artistic cohesion simply wasn’t there.

That said, I appreciated a few standout pieces that gave Ruby and Weiss extra charm. A handful of artists managed to capture the essence of the characters beautifully enough that I paused to admire a panel before turning the page.

Who Should Read This Anthology?

If you’re a newcomer curious about RWBY, I’ll be blunt: this is not where you should start. The anthologies don’t bother explaining the world of Remnant, the Grimm, or even the basics of Beacon Academy. Without that context, much of the humor and tension will fly over your head.

But if you’re already a RWBY fan, these books act like bonus content. They won’t expand the lore or push the plot forward, but they will give you small, character-driven snapshots. Think of them as side quests sometimes fun, sometimes forgettable, but rarely essential.

For me, they scratched a nostalgic itch but didn’t leave a lasting impression. I wouldn’t call them bad, but they’re undeniably niche.

A Flawed but Fun Companion

After finishing both volumes, I walked away with a mix of amusement and frustration. The inconsistent art, scattered storytelling, and shallow character beats kept these anthologies from being truly great. At the same time, there were moments like Ruby’s silly boyfriend quest or Weiss’s weaponized cookies that made me smile.

Reading on ComicK made the experience smoother, since I didn’t have to hunt down copies or worry about translation quality. The site’s easy navigation and free access let me enjoy the stories without extra hassle. But ultimately, whether you’ll enjoy this anthology depends entirely on how much you already love RWBY.

For die-hard fans, RWBY: Official Manga Anthology offers charming little windows into Ruby and Weiss’s worlds. For casual readers, though, it may feel like an inconsistent detour rather than a rewarding journey.

Read more:

Review Comic